Flat illustration of a small beach house with palm trees and a flattening line chart above it, in navy, blue and teal.

Is a Costa Rica Vacation Rental Still Worth It? Tourism Slows

If you are weighing a vacation rental in Costa Rica, the question this month is whether guests will keep arriving at the pace your income estimate assumes. September arrivals fell 2.4% from a year earlier, so buyers of beach homes and condos meant for short-term rental should build their numbers on flat demand, not growth. This guide is written mainly for expat buyers and for owners who already rent out a property.

Key takeaways

  • September international arrivals fell 2.4% to 118,888, and US arrivals have now dropped two months in a row.
  • The average Costa Rican short-term rental books 43.7% of nights and earns about $16,606 a year, roughly half of what a simple rate-times-nights sum suggests.
  • Underwrite on the lower figure, and confirm registration and tax status with a Costa Rican attorney before you commit.

What Happened

On 16 October the Centro de Estudios del Turismo (CET, a tourism research centre) published its note on September arrivals, built on Tourism Institute (ICT) figures that come from immigration records. Separately, a CET study of the year to July 2026 sized the short-term rental market. Together they give buyers a demand reading and a supply reading.

  • September arrivals by all routes were 118,888, down 2.4% from 121,815 a year earlier. Air arrivals fell 1.7% to 102,474 and land arrivals fell 5% to 16,273 (El Mundo CR).
  • The same report calls it the weakest September since 2021 and about 25.8% below September 2019.
  • US arrivals fell 3.3% in September after a 13.7% fall in August, though the US still supplied 55.7% of year-to-date arrivals. Canada rose 18.9% in September (Diario Extra).
  • January to September arrivals were 2,310,320, up 4.8%. The first quarter grew 11.3%, but April to September added only about 1,480 visitors, up 0.1%. A separate El Financiero report puts air-arrival growth at 5.4% for the nine months, so check which basis a source uses.
  • The CET rental study counts 48,985 active listings in about 243 locations, up from about 22,500 in 2019, with $813.5 million of revenue, an average nightly rate of $204 and 43.7% occupancy (Semanario Universidad).

Chart: Average nightly rate by lodging type, US dollars (hotels and non-traditional lodging as reported March 2026; rentals July 2025 to July 2026)

Hotels$302Non-hotel lodging$234Rentals, nationwide$204Rentals, San Jose area$61Source: Colliers via El Financiero (3 Mar 2026); CET via Semanario Universidad (16 Sep 2026)
Lodging typeAverage nightly rate (USD)Average occupancy
Hotels302about 65%
Non-hotel lodging234about 43%
Short-term rentals, nationwide20443.7%
Short-term rentals, Greater San Jose6150%
Sources: Colliers via El Financiero, 3 March 2026 (hotels, non-hotel lodging); CET via Semanario Universidad, 16 September 2026 (rentals). Periods differ, so compare with care.

What This Means If You Are Buying

The assets most exposed are coastal houses and condos bought mainly to rent to foreign guests. The CET reports that in the Guanacaste luxury corridor (Tamarindo, Cabo Velas, Nosara, Sardinal and Tempate/Potrero) 1,193 listings charge roughly $214 to $384 a night, and that Nosara guests are mostly American. A buyer there leans on the market that is currently weakest, so a US slowdown hits that segment first. Greater San Jose apartments sit at the other end: about $61 a night, 50% occupancy and about $7,200 a year per listing, which the source describes as about a third of the coastal average (we did not find the coastal figure itself). The same arithmetic gap appears here: $61 x 50% x 365 is about $11,130, well above $7,200.

Here is where the numbers fail to add up. Multiply the national rate of $204 by 43.7% occupancy over 365 days and you get about $32,500 a year. The reported average income per listing is $16,606 (La Nacion). We have not found an official explanation for the gap. Our read, not a forecast: many listings are probably not open all year, and a buyer who expects the full-year result is likely to be disappointed. The CET also notes that income is rising because rates are rising, not because more nights are sold.

ItemFigureWho says so
Active rental listings48,985 (about 22,500 in 2019)CET via La Nacion, 10 Sep 2026
Average income per listing, a year$16,606 nationwide; about $7,200 Greater San JoseLa Nacion; Semanario Universidad
Hotel rate and occupancy$302; about 65%Colliers via El Financiero, 3 Mar 2026
Non-hotel lodging rate and occupancy$234; about 43%Colliers via El Financiero, 3 Mar 2026
Owner costs (management, cleaning, fees, utilities, property tax)No verified all-in figure foundLeft blank on purpose
Verified items only, as of 19 October 2026. We do not use promoter or broker return claims; any such claim is self-reported and unverified.

On who pays what: the owner carries platform fees, cleaning, management, utilities, insurance and property taxes, and we could not verify all-in figures for these, so check them line by line. On tax, a commercial explainer (Hostaway) cites 12.75% on platform rental income and 13% VAT on stays, but hedges on both. We could not find authoritative Hacienda guidance confirming the rate in this research, so treat it as unconfirmed. El Financiero reports that running non-traditional lodging without ICT registration is illegal under Law 9742.

What Could Go Wrong

  • Demand concentration: the US supplies 55.7% of year-to-date arrivals, and its recent drop is not yet explained by the sources we read.
  • Supply: listings have more than doubled since 2019 while September arrivals sit about 25.8% below September 2019, so you compete with more homes for each guest.
  • Price competitiveness: the CET flags a stronger colon, which makes Costa Rica dearer for dollar-paying guests.
  • Compliance: an unregistered or untaxed rental can face fines or closure, and a seller’s past non-compliance can pass to you as a problem to fix.
  • Seasonality and revisions: August to October is the low season, and arrival data can be revised, so one weak month is not a trend.

The upside case: Canadian arrivals are up sharply (up 24.8% for January to August by air, per El Financiero), Europe is growing, and the first nine months are still up 4.8%. For the weak spell to be temporary, we would need to see US arrivals turn positive in the October to December data, rental occupancy rise above the 43.7% average, and listing growth slow.

Your Next Steps

  • Expat buyers: ask any seller for 24 months of booking statements from the platform itself, not a summary, and compare the nights booked with the 43.7% average.
  • Property owners: check that your ICT registration and municipal paperwork are current, and ask your accountant which rate applies to your platform income.
  • Local investors: ask whether your costs are in colones while your revenue is in dollars, since a stronger colon squeezes that margin.
  • Developers and hotel buyers: compare your forecast occupancy with the roughly 65% hotels average and ask what justifies any figure above it. Our read, not a forecast: price your base case on flat arrivals.

Hire a Costa Rican attorney or notary for your own transaction; this article cannot replace one.

What to watch next: the ICT and CET October arrivals figures, which on this month’s timing should appear around mid-November (date not confirmed).

Run Your Own Numbers

Fill in the table for a property you are considering. A home or rental buyer can use it for one house, a lender can use it to test a borrower’s income claim, and a fund allocator can run it for each asset in a portfolio. Start from booked nights, not from the listing rate.

InputYour assumptionEffect on yearly income
Nightly rate you can show with real bookings  
Nights booked a year (occupancy x 365)  
Months the property is actually open  
Costs and taxes confirmed by your advisor  

Illustration only, not a forecast. This is a hypothetical check using national averages: 43.7% occupancy x 365 days is about 159.5 nights, and 159.5 nights x $204 is about $32,539 a year. The reported average per listing is $16,606, so the simple sum is nearly double (32,539 / 16,606 is about 1.96). A buyer who pays for the higher figure is relying on a result the average listing does not achieve.

Questions to take to a sponsor, advisor or counterparty

  • Can you show platform statements for the last two full years, including the months the property was closed?
  • Which guest nationalities make up most bookings, and what happens to income if that market falls 10%?
  • Is the property registered with the ICT, and which taxes have been paid on past rental income?

Resumen en español

  • Las llegadas internacionales de setiembre cayeron 2,4% a 118.888, y las de Estados Unidos bajaron 3,3% tras caer 13,7% en agosto.
  • El alquiler de corta estancia promedio tiene 43,7% de ocupación y genera cerca de $16.606 al año, casi la mitad de lo que sugiere multiplicar tarifa por noches.
  • Calcule con el dato más bajo, confirme el registro ante el ICT con un abogado costarricense y espere los datos de octubre (alrededor de mediados de noviembre, fecha sin confirmar).

Related reading: A Stronger Colon Is a Currency-Mismatch Test for Costa Rica Deals; Costa Rica’s 2026 Short-Term Rental Tax Enforcement; and our hotel buyer guide.


Data as of 19 October 2026. Figures marked preliminary will be revised. This is general market commentary, not investment advice.

Sources

Pura Vida 👋
It’s nice to meet you.

Sign up to receive the latest insights in your inbox, every month.

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Need this analysis for a specific deal?

We research the market, the asset and the rules behind your decision, sourced and dated, in English or Spanish.

Get the Next One in Your Inbox

No noise, no sales pitch — just the research, when it’s published.

Next step: check your inbox (and spam folder) for our confirmation email and click the link to start receiving the research.

Related Insights

More From Investor Insights

Leave a Reply